About US



At Ashlin Hadden Insurance, we don’t like to say we sell liability insurance to Amazon sellers; we like to say we protect sellers’ dreams because we believe in them. Our sellers become part of our family.


What We Practice


Ashlin Hadden Insurance is a dedicated, solutions-oriented company that strives each day to act with integrity and wisdom. We seek to listen, educate, engage and be the industry leader in protecting our clients’ assets. We promise to always provide solutions, generate positivity, work with passion, and be the guardians of what matters most to our clients.



What We Aspire To


We strive to be the insurance agency of choice that is dedicated to educating, serving, and protecting the things that matter most to our clients – their families, their assets, and their livelihood. We do this on a local and global scale by providing unparalleled service and the highest quality insurance plans at competitive rates.




Meet the Business


‘I don’t want you to think about insurance every time you think of me. But I do want you to think of me, every time you think about insurance.” ~ Ashlin Hadden, founder

Owner and CEO, Ashlin Hadden, has been in the insurance sector for over a decade. She spent her first few years with a large insurance company, learning everything there was to know about the insurance products she was selling and the clients she worked with. When she went out on her own in 2017, she promised herself that her company would always place principles and morale before money and notoriety. Ashlin has made it her mission as CEO to hire knowledgeable, top-tier agents, to create a loving and nurturing work environment, and to cultivate relationships with her clients that extend beyond insurance. When it comes to providing quality service and products, her skillset is unmatched.

The staff here prides itself on being small yet effective. Personable yet professional. Fun yet serious about insurance.

When we say our clients become our family, we mean it.




Meet the Family


Ashlin Hadden


Ashlin has enjoyed a long career in the insurance sector, most notably working at a high-profile job at a well-renowned insurance agency. In 2017, Ashlin left to start her own brokerage firm and almost immediately began working with carriers to write eCommerce insurance policies before eCom insurance even existed. She’s a bright and bubbly spitfire that genuinely cares about her clients’ success. You can always find Ashlin wherever there are tater tots.

Lindsey Caudill

Office Manager

Lindsey has worked in administration, office management, and human resources for the past 20 years. She strives to support employees in their jobs and help the office operate smoothly and efficiently. Lindsey has an eclectic taste in music and you never know what you’ll hear playing in her office. 


Office Coordinator

Cassie came to the agency with over 15 years of customer service experience. Being new to the insurance world, she is excited to put hard work into helping our customers. She is a cat lover and if she finds a stray around the office, it might just become an office cat! Her biggest love is her family, especially her two littles.

Sarah Fahlsing

Ecommerce Service Manager

Since 2013, Sarah has been in the insurance industry, helping clients understand and meet their insurance needs. She prides herself on focusing on the customer and their business, ensuring that they feel good about their coverage and doing business with us. Sarah is a huge animal-lover, even saving spiders by releasing them outdoors.

Kelsey Taulbee

Ecommerce Insurance Manager

Kelsey has been a small business owner for 14 years which makes her relatable to our clients. Her passion for great service shows because she always has a smile on her face. She takes amazing care of both her customers and the staff here as well. 

Amanda Hill

Commercial Standard Lines New Business Manager

Amanda has several years of experience servicing customers in the insurance industry. She prides herself on being detail-oriented and anticipating the needs of her customers. You will find Amanda at her standing desk in her warm, cozy office because she always has her space heater on, no matter the time of year.

Hannah Agresti

Licensed Renewal Advocate

Hannah started working in the insurance field in the beginning of 2022 and was a quick and astute learner in the commercial insurance world. She is a small business owner herself, crafting and selling French macarons out of her home, and is excited to use that passion to help direct and protect others. With a background in social work, she has a heart for serving others and a dedication to detail.

Blaire Duncan

Personal & Commercial Lines Insurance Advisor

Meet Blaire, your go-to gal in the insurance industry! She’s an Indiana native with a wealth of knowledge and experience in the insurance industry. Blaire is a dedicated fan of the Dave Matthews Band, having seen them live over 40 times, AND naming her two cats after members of the band. Her dedication doesn’t end there though. Blaire is dedicated to finding tailored solutions that meet all her client’s needs and help them protect what matters most. Her passion for pickles is almost as great as her passion for helping her clients navigate the complexities of insurance. When she’s not in the office you can find her at her other job: being the cool aunt to an adorable little girl! Whether you’re seeking coverage for your home, business, or anything in between, Blaire is committed to providing top-notch service and ensuring peace of mind for her clients.


Personal Lines Advocate

Sam is a recent transplant from Wisconsin and has worked in customer service most of her adult life. She is beyond excited to start this new journey in the insurance world. With her hard work at Ashlin Hadden Insurance coupled with raising 5 kids, it’s no wonder you can always find her with a coffee in hand. 

Maggie Rohrer

Marketing Ambassador

Maggie has worked in the marketing and social media sector for several years and is so excited to join the Ashlin Hadden team. She prides herself on being knowledgeable and passionate when it comes to marketing, as well as being a person people can rely on. Her favorite food is tacos, and her life mission is to find the best al pastor taco in the U.S.

Morgan Pruss

Marketing Assistant

Morgan is a recent graduate from Butler University where she studied marketing and management information systems. She is excited to bring her knowledge and creativity to the insurance world. With a love for marketing and design, she is eager to showcase all the amazing things our agency can bring to everyone.

Gabriela Vergara

Life Insurance & Disability Strategist

Gabriela is known for her positive, adaptable & dynamic personality. She’s excited to use her bilingual experience & knowledge to assist hardworking families, individuals & business owners in protecting themselves, their families, and assets. Her love for people shines through her individualized & tailored approach. Dedication & consistency are words she displays both in her career & when she lifts heavy weights at the gym.

Jessica Cook

Licensed Service Advocate

Meet Jessica, born and raised in the heart of Texas. Jessica’s adventurous spirit is ignited by her love for the great outdoors. Whether it’s hiking through the rugged hill country, camping under the vast starry Indiana sky, or just sitting by the fire with beloved friends, she cherishes creating moments that will build fantastic memories that last a lifetime.

Valerie Guilds

Personal Lines Operations Manager

Valerie Guilds is an expert in the insurance industry who possesses the licensing and experience needed to offer the best possible service to her customers. Her mission is to build customized insurance policies tailored to each client’s specific personal, business or life insurance needs. As your insurance agent, Valerie can advise you on a multitude of products and services, including home and auto insurance, commercial property coverage and life insurance.

Ashlin Hadden gets involved with the community.

Get In Touch


10911 Greenfield Ave
Noblesville, IN 46060
+1 (765) 432-8989